What metrics should a CMO review weekly for a consumer brand?
What metrics should a CMO review weekly for a consumer brand? A short scorecard built on business numbers, not ad platform dashboards: net revenue vs plan, MER (net revenue ÷ total marketing spend), new customers and new-customer CAC, contribution margin after marketing, CAC payback on recent cohorts, and repeat or second-purchase rate, plus one leading indicator per channel. Platform ROAS belongs one level down, as a tool for comparing campaigns inside a channel, because every platform grades its own homework and the totals never add up to Shopify.
Review seven numbers every week: (1) net revenue vs plan, (2) MER, (3) new customers and new-customer CAC, (4) contribution margin after marketing, (5) CAC payback on the last 3 to 6 monthly cohorts, (6) 30, 60 and 90-day repeat rate, and (7) one leading indicator per channel (creative hit rate, email list growth, conversion rate). Read them as trends against last week and the 4-week average, and use platform ROAS only to allocate budget within a channel.
Most weekly marketing meetings at consumer brands doing $75K to $500K a month open the same way: someone shares Ads Manager, someone shares Google Ads, and the room argues about which ROAS is right. That meeting can run for an hour without answering the only question a CMO needs answered each week: is the business getting more customers, at a cost it can afford, with margin left over? The scorecard below answers that in about 30 minutes.
Why platform ROAS is the wrong weekly headline
- Platforms overlap. Each platform counts conversions inside its own attribution window, often including view-through and modeled conversions, so Meta, Google and TikTok together usually claim more revenue than the store actually booked. See why Meta-reported revenue doesn't match Shopify.
- ROAS mixes new and returning buyers. A campaign retargeting existing customers can show high ROAS while new-customer growth stalls. See new-customer ROAS vs blended ROAS.
- ROAS ignores margin. A 3.0 ROAS on a 40% gross-margin product and a 3.0 ROAS on a 70% gross-margin product are different businesses. Break-even ROAS is roughly 1 ÷ margin, so the first needs about 2.5 just to cover product cost and the second about 1.4. See MER vs break-even ROAS.
The weekly CMO scorecard
| Metric | How to calculate | What a bad week looks like | Source of truth |
|---|---|---|---|
| Net revenue vs plan | Shopify net sales (after refunds and discounts, excluding tax) vs the weekly target | Below plan two weeks running | Shopify or ERP |
| MER | Net revenue ÷ total marketing spend across all channels (include agency and tool fees if you choose, but be consistent) | Falling while spend is flat | Shopify plus a spend ledger |
| New customers and new-customer CAC | First-time buyers; total acquisition spend ÷ new customers | CAC up, new customers flat | Shopify customer data |
| New-customer revenue share | First-order revenue ÷ net revenue | Growth coming only from returning buyers | Shopify |
| Contribution margin after marketing | Net revenue minus COGS, shipping, payment fees, returns and marketing spend | Revenue up, contribution flat or down | Finance model |
| CAC payback (recent cohorts) | Months until a cohort's cumulative contribution margin covers its CAC | Newest cohorts paying back slower | Cohort sheet |
| Repeat or second-purchase rate | Share of first-order customers with a second paid order within 30, 60 or 90 days | Newest cohorts trailing older ones | Shopify cohorts or Klaviyo |
| Channel leading indicators | For example new creative hit rate, conversion rate, email and SMS list growth, subscription failed-payment recovery | Pipeline of winners drying up | Channel tools |
Two definitions matter more than any formula. First, pick one revenue number (net sales, excluding tax, after refunds) and never switch it mid-quarter. Second, keep one spend ledger that every channel's cost lands in, including creators and agencies if you count them. Most broken scorecards fail on definitions, not math.
How to run the 30-minute weekly review
- Start with revenue vs plan and MER. If both are fine, move fast.
- Check new customers and new-customer CAC. This is where scaling problems show first, often a week or two before revenue moves.
- Check contribution margin after marketing. Growth that does not reach contribution is a spend problem, not a win.
- Glance at the payback and repeat trend on the newest cohorts. Monthly is enough for depth; weekly is a trend check. For targets, see what a healthy CAC payback looks like.
- Only then open channel dashboards. Decide where the next dollar goes using platform ROAS and new-customer ROAS inside each channel.
- Write down one decision and one owner. A scorecard without a decision is a report, not a review.
The scorecard decides whether to spend more. Platform dashboards decide where. When they disagree on direction, the store numbers win.
A one-page layout you can copy
Build it in a sheet with one row per metric and these columns. Fill it from Shopify and your spend ledger every Monday for the previous full week, pulled on the same dates for every source.
| Metric | This week | Last week | 4-week average | Plan | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Net revenue | Net of refunds, excluding tax | ||||
| MER | All channels, one ledger | ||||
| New customers / CAC | Store-first, not platform | ||||
| Contribution after marketing | Dollars and % of revenue | ||||
| Payback, newest cohort | Monthly cohort, trend only | ||||
| Repeat rate, 30 days | Cohort that hit 30 days this week | ||||
| Leading indicator per channel | One per channel, no more | ||||
| Decision this week: ______ Owner: ______ | |||||
Report in USD, or in your home currency for brands in the UK, EU, Australia or the UAE. The method does not change.
Weekly vs monthly vs quarterly: what not to over-read
| Weekly | Monthly | Quarterly |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue vs plan, MER, new customers, CAC, contribution trend, leading indicators | Cohort payback, 60 and 90-day repeat, LTV by first product, channel incrementality reads | Pricing, assortment, budget mix, team and agency scope |
Adjusting the scorecard by revenue band
- At $75K to $150K a month, keep it to five numbers: revenue vs plan, MER, new customers, CAC and contribution. Data volume is too thin for weekly cohort reads.
- At $150K to $500K a month, add cohort payback and repeat rate, plus one holdout or incrementality read per quarter for your biggest channel.
- At every band, one spend ledger, one revenue definition, one owner of the sheet.
Repeat rate is where lifecycle work shows up on the scorecard. If the newest cohorts trail older ones, start with post-purchase emails that drive a second purchase, and for subscription brands check involuntary churn and dunning before blaming acquisition. For how these numbers connect into one operating system, see the Growthitt engine.
FAQ
What metrics should a CMO review weekly for a consumer brand?
Net revenue vs plan, MER, new customers and new-customer CAC, contribution margin after marketing, CAC payback on recent cohorts, repeat rate, and one leading indicator per channel. Read each one against last week, the 4-week average and plan.
Why shouldn't platform ROAS be the main weekly KPI?
Platforms self-attribute with different windows and modeled conversions, mix new and returning buyers, and ignore margin, so their totals rarely match the store. Platform ROAS is useful for comparing campaigns inside one channel, not for judging the business.
What is MER and why does it matter weekly?
Marketing efficiency ratio is net revenue divided by total marketing spend. It is hard to game and shows whether the whole system is getting more or less efficient, whichever channel the platforms claim drove the sale.
How is new-customer CAC different from cost per purchase in Ads Manager?
New-customer CAC uses total acquisition spend divided by first-time buyers from your store data. Cost per purchase in Ads Manager uses platform-reported purchases, which include returning customers and sales other platforms also claim.
Should CAC payback be reviewed weekly?
Check the trend weekly, but calculate it on monthly cohorts. Weekly cohorts are usually too small for stable payback reads at the $75K to $500K a month revenue band.
What is a good weekly scorecard format?
One page: each metric in a row, with columns for this week, last week, the 4-week average and plan, plus a single decision and owner at the bottom. Keep one revenue definition and one spend ledger behind it.
Where do email and SMS fit in a CMO scorecard?
Through repeat rate and second-purchase rate by cohort, plus list growth as a leading indicator, rather than flow open rates. Email and SMS earn their place by moving repeat revenue and payback.
When does a scorecard problem need a Diagnosis?
When MER and platform ROAS disagree for weeks, nobody owns the revenue definition, or new-customer CAC is rising and you cannot say which channel or cohort caused it.
Not sure which number is lying?
A growth operator reviews your acquisition, conversion, retention, and measurement live, then sends a prioritised roadmap within 24 hours. We rebuild your weekly scorecard from Shopify and spend data and put a revenue estimate on every fix.
Request a Growth Diagnosis →